$7k repair!

Joined
Feb 20, 2025
Messages
5
Reaction score
1
My mechanic recently diagnosed our 2019 Subaru Outback (48k miles) with an oil leak he thought had been there for at least a year (not caught by the dealership!). He told me it was beyond his scope of repair & that I would need to take it back to the dealership, and it would most likely cost 6 ~ 8 thousand dollars to repair. The dealership charged me a $285 diagnostic fee to tell me the exact same thing my mechanic told me for free, then handed me the $7k estimate! I did contact Subaru of America to file a claim. They will be covering $4k of the repairs, but I still feel like $3k is pretty outrageous.

We've taken great care of our vehicle since we purchased it in September 2019. The first 4 years at the dealership. In the past year alone... we had the battery replaced (this was after another $275 diagnostic charge from our Subaru dealership in July), all new tires, new rear brakes, new air/cabin filter, a recent oil change & tune-up, all for a total of $3k.

This was the final response I got from SOA regarding what was wrong with our vehicle...
Thank you for your thoughtful message. I completely understand your concerns, particularly in light of your past experience with your previous Subaru. It’s incredibly frustrating to encounter significant repairs after purchasing a new vehicle, and I empathize with your situation. No one expects to face these kinds of challenges, especially after making such a large investment.

In regard to the engine reseal, this type of repair, while not common, can sometimes be necessary due to a variety of factors, including natural wear and tear, environmental conditions, or even the specific design of the engine itself. Over time, as a vehicle is driven under different conditions, certain engine components, such as gaskets or seals, may begin to deteriorate. This can cause minor leaks, typically related to oil or coolant, which will require resealing to restore the engine’s optimal performance and prevent further damage.

While it may seem like an unusual or unexpected repair, it's important to note that this kind of issue can happen with any vehicle as it ages or if exposed to harsher conditions, such as extreme temperatures or frequent short trips that don’t allow the engine to fully warm up. This repair isn’t specific to Subaru, and we do not typically see it across all of our vehicles. However, it’s something that occasionally comes up as part of routine vehicle maintenance or wear.

If you're still with me, thanks so much for hearing me out :)
I'd appreciate any feedback from others who may have experienced anything like this.
And hope it may help others in the future!
 
My mechanic recently diagnosed our 2019 Subaru Outback (48k miles) with an oil leak he thought had been there for at least a year (not caught by the dealership!). He told me it was beyond his scope of repair & that I would need to take it back to the dealership, and it would most likely cost 6 ~ 8 thousand dollars to repair. The dealership charged me a $285 diagnostic fee to tell me the exact same thing my mechanic told me for free, then handed me the $7k estimate! I did contact Subaru of America to file a claim. They will be covering $4k of the repairs, but I still feel like $3k is pretty outrageous.

We've taken great care of our vehicle since we purchased it in September 2019. The first 4 years at the dealership. In the past year alone... we had the battery replaced (this was after another $275 diagnostic charge from our Subaru dealership in July), all new tires, new rear brakes, new air/cabin filter, a recent oil change & tune-up, all for a total of $3k.

This was the final response I got from SOA regarding what was wrong with our vehicle...
Thank you for your thoughtful message. I completely understand your concerns, particularly in light of your past experience with your previous Subaru. It’s incredibly frustrating to encounter significant repairs after purchasing a new vehicle, and I empathize with your situation. No one expects to face these kinds of challenges, especially after making such a large investment.

In regard to the engine reseal, this type of repair, while not common, can sometimes be necessary due to a variety of factors, including natural wear and tear, environmental conditions, or even the specific design of the engine itself. Over time, as a vehicle is driven under different conditions, certain engine components, such as gaskets or seals, may begin to deteriorate. This can cause minor leaks, typically related to oil or coolant, which will require resealing to restore the engine’s optimal performance and prevent further damage.

While it may seem like an unusual or unexpected repair, it's important to note that this kind of issue can happen with any vehicle as it ages or if exposed to harsher conditions, such as extreme temperatures or frequent short trips that don’t allow the engine to fully warm up. This repair isn’t specific to Subaru, and we do not typically see it across all of our vehicles. However, it’s something that occasionally comes up as part of routine vehicle maintenance or wear.

If you're still with me, thanks so much for hearing me out :)
I'd appreciate any feedback from others who may have experienced anything like this.
And hope it may help others in the future!

We had a very similar experience with an older Impreza. Front cover seal leak parts are like $400 and Labor is the rest, as they remove engine, I told them this was inexorable and I would be calling a local news station to complain about the company not standing behind their product and ours had 121k on it, submitted to SOA also and was persistent, that we settled on $500 to fix it all. The dealership literally told me ALL SUBARUS LEAK OIL, like I was just supposed to accept that, well I did and I sold that piece of crap and WILL NEVER GIVE SUBARU MY BUSINESS AGAIN .
 
We've taken great care of our vehicle since we purchased it in September 2019. The first 4 years at the dealership. In the past year alone... we had the battery replaced (this was after another $275 diagnostic charge from our Subaru dealership in July), all new tires, new rear brakes, new air/cabin filter, a recent oil change & tune-up, all for a total of $3k.
you didn't say where the leak was, but considerign the cost, I'm guessing it's the timing chain cover which basically covers the entire front of the engine and requires and engine pull to repair. it's a bad design, they did away with gaskets and just use siliocne here. it has ot be applied perfectly, and the engine oil kept very clean (5K miles max), or it will eat thie silicone away. The nice factory letter from their PR dept is right about one thing, all of them got rid of gaskets to save cost and this problem is very common on all cars, even sometihng like a V6 Lexus

AFA the other costs, try and find a private shop that specialize in subauru . Ther cabin air filter is a 5 minute job, you would be amwzed how simple it is. dealer typically charges $120. to $200.
The big red flag is the " tune -up", there's no such thing as a tuneup on modern cars. There no points to adjust, or carbuearator mixture screws, etc. Spark plugs can be called a tune-up item if your an old dinosaur mechanic like me , but Iridium plugs are good for 100k miles. The only thing they tuned-up is their bottom line
 
nothing really inherently bad or worng with these cars, althoguh i think 2015 to 2019 had he least problems overall. I think a lot of your costs are just dealer abuses. They don't call them stealerships for no reason
the generation after this one have " thermal control valve" issues (engine) which they recently got rid of in 2024 or 25
 
The first generation FB25s used RTV sealant instead of a gasket - after about 8 years or so I've heard the seals wear out. The common repair price for that I've seen is about $3,000, with the engine needing to be removed. I thought it was not a common occurrence in later years - such as 2018 a newer. And, I wouldn't think a 2019 would have the leaks already.
 
interesting, i didn't know that. My kid drives a 2013 OB and no leaks at 135k miles. Maybe it depends on other factors?
Assembly line skill, oil changes, ? who knows
Maybe it does depend on other factors. My 2012 Forester has no signs yet of the cam carrier leak yet - so I don't know if it's a given. Like you said, I've heard timely oil changes can help and who knows, maybe the day of the week it was made.
 
we had the battery replaced (this was after another $275 diagnostic charge from our Subaru dealership in July), all new tires, new rear brakes, new air/cabin filter, a recent oil change & tune-up, all for a total of $3k.
but did you top off the oil every 500 miles?
 
My mechanic recently diagnosed our 2019 Subaru Outback (48k miles) with an oil leak he thought had been there for at least a year (not caught by the dealership!). He told me it was beyond his scope of repair & that I would need to take it back to the dealership, and it would most likely cost 6 ~ 8 thousand dollars to repair. The dealership charged me a $285 diagnostic fee to tell me the exact same thing my mechanic told me for free, then handed me the $7k estimate! I did contact Subaru of America to file a claim. They will be covering $4k of the repairs, but I still feel like $3k is pretty outrageous.

We've taken great care of our vehicle since we purchased it in September 2019. The first 4 years at the dealership. In the past year alone... we had the battery replaced (this was after another $275 diagnostic charge from our Subaru dealership in July), all new tires, new rear brakes, new air/cabin filter, a recent oil change & tune-up, all for a total of $3k.

This was the final response I got from SOA regarding what was wrong with our vehicle...
Thank you for your thoughtful message. I completely understand your concerns, particularly in light of your past experience with your previous Subaru. It’s incredibly frustrating to encounter significant repairs after purchasing a new vehicle, and I empathize with your situation. No one expects to face these kinds of challenges, especially after making such a large investment.

In regard to the engine reseal, this type of repair, while not common, can sometimes be necessary due to a variety of factors, including natural wear and tear, environmental conditions, or even the specific design of the engine itself. Over time, as a vehicle is driven under different conditions, certain engine components, such as gaskets or seals, may begin to deteriorate. This can cause minor leaks, typically related to oil or coolant, which will require resealing to restore the engine’s optimal performance and prevent further damage.

While it may seem like an unusual or unexpected repair, it's important to note that this kind of issue can happen with any vehicle as it ages or if exposed to harsher conditions, such as extreme temperatures or frequent short trips that don’t allow the engine to fully warm up. This repair isn’t specific to Subaru, and we do not typically see it across all of our vehicles. However, it’s something that occasionally comes up as part of routine vehicle maintenance or wear.

If you're still with me, thanks so much for hearing me out :)
I'd appreciate any feedback from others who may have experienced anything like this.
And hope it may help others in the future!

I've owned (and worked on) various cars for 50 years now. it is inconceivable to me that the Subaru dealership could not have diagnosed a gasket/ seal problem resulting in 'minor oil' leaks. that now requires 7K of 're-sealing' ' gasket and seal' components on a 6-year old vehicle with only 48K miles. (our 07 Chevrolet 3500 w/ it s 8-cyl 6.0 L Vortec engine has not required 7 K of work in its entire life, let alone 7K for gaskets and seals.. )

a 2021 Subaru Forester owner
 
Have you been to a dealer recently? The service aspect is embarrassing. They appear to have been actually trained in...nothing.

A friend recently took his bike to the local "dealer." They told him ~$16k to repair as it needed an engine overhaul. What it really needed was a $150 clutch. Another friend had a very similar vehicle experience, but only $12k was used...he had only all loose spark plugs from the last "expert."

There's a reason they're called stealerships.
 
Have you been to a dealer recently? The service aspect is embarrassing. They appear to have been actually trained in...nothing.
it's a Jungle out there, and the Monkey's are in charge ;)

my 06 impreza / 246K miles is still going, but it's unreasonable to think it will last forever. I'm not sure what to get, but one thing for sure, nothing made after 2019 at the very latest
 
I prefer the Legacy platform, but even older. They're just...so much better than the newer ones. Just picked up a JDM I have to run through before putting it on the road. My '00 has 212k miles of use on it and still work like a top...virtually no dealer trips unless I got lazy.
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
15,319
Messages
72,770
Members
8,959
Latest member
TheBoobaruDude

Latest Threads

Back
Top