New air filter?

Patrick F. Clarin

Usenet Archive
Joined
Aug 21, 2003
Messages
20
Reaction score
0
How much difference can a new air filter make on my '02 WRX? Especially one of those supposedly high performance ones from K&N.
 
Patrick F. Clarin said:
How much difference can a new air filter make on my '02 WRX? Especially one of those supposedly high performance ones from K&N.

Big difference i put one in my SVX.

Richard
 
Made NO difference on my 2000 Forester except made it sound louder and cost more so now I run OEM
 
If you go with a new intake that will accept a LARGER filter then you could expect improvements in airflow. If you get an improvement in flow with a stock size filter I would expect more dirt entering the intake...not good!
TG
 
How much difference can a new air filter make on my '02 WRX? Especially one of those supposedly high performance ones from K&N.

A world of difference. Better mileage, acceleration. Best easy upgrade out there
 
goto http://www.subarureview.com It has all the info you will need. I 'm not sure what TG is talking about. I have a '04 WRX and from all I have read our stock intake is good upto 350 hp with a panel filter like K&N. As for getting a "larger filter" such as the cold air intake(CAI) and such will throw off The computer on the WRX. It will make the engine lean out and ping early and make the knock sensor set the timming back and make you loose power. TG what "larger filter" are you talking about?
 
In
Jkpoulos7 said:
A world of difference. Better mileage, acceleration. Best easy upgrade out there

Yep, and shorter engine life due to the small-size crap no longer trapped by the air filter.
 
Ned Pike said:
In

Yep, and shorter engine life due to the small-size crap no longer trapped by the air filter.

A cite of some actual data would help a lot. Got any empirical data?
 
Jkpoulos7 said:
A world of difference. Better mileage, acceleration. Best easy upgrade out there

I've seen dyno tests in an auto mag (Motor Trend?) showing that a K&N cone filter had slightly improved top-end power by a few HP in a '94 Integra LS, but actually decreased lower end power (under 2K). I think Honda got it right with a dual stage intake that opens up at higher RPMs. Restricting the airflow is supposed to help with lower end power/driveability.

I agree with some of the other posters that it may do more harm than good unless there's some modification to the engine computer to account for the increased airflow. I also recall K&N's own info saying that paper filters were better at trapping contaminants.
 
In

Yep, and shorter engine life due to the small-size crap no longer trapped by the air filter.

Absolute rubbish. Proper performance filters are just as effective as the standard part, if not more so. You simply have to remember to re-oil them every 10,000 miles or so - or more frequently if you live somewhere with a lot of airborn dust or drive off road. Other than that, no problem.

Not sure that K&N is necessarily the best bet in a Rex, though. I'm pretty sure Scoobysport recommend something else. Take a look at their web site.

David Betts
 
"
Yep, and shorter engine life due to the small-size crap no longer trapped by the air filter.

I somehow doubt that. Put a K&N in my 94 Trooper at about 15k miles. Still had in in there at 145K when it was totalled. NO engine issues whatsoever.
 
My understanding, admittedly limited, is that "Yes" the new (K&N or similar) air filter will enhance performance on a race track but not in real world driving.
 
David Betts said:
Absolute rubbish. Proper performance filters are just as effective as the standard part, if not more so. You simply have to remember to re-oil them every 10,000 miles or so - or more frequently if you live somewhere with a lot of airborn dust or drive off road. Other than that, no problem.

Not sure that K&N is necessarily the best bet in a Rex, though. I'm pretty sure Scoobysport recommend something else. Take a look at their web site.

I've used a K&N filter before. Their own literature claims that their oiled gauze filters are more effective at trapping dirt when dirt has already built up, which increases the surface area. Of course when the dirt builds up, there's going to be more restriction.
 
Jkpoulos7 said:
A world of difference. Better mileage, acceleration. Best easy upgrade out there

I sort of believe, but may need a little more convincing. Anybody do a G-Tek run before & after?

Actually I'm a lot more interested in how it affects an NA 2.5l Sube than a WRX. Still hard data beats "butt dyno."
 
This subject comes up quite frequently on the Mazda Miata ng too. A friend of mine on "scoobymods" (Peaty) got me to put a K&N in my 97 Outback back in
1999. He also talked me into removing the air "snorkel" from inside the passenger side front fender, in order to get more cold air into the air box. I probably gained maybe 1 or 2 hp from what I've been told, but the engine seems to spool up much quicker. I'm really happy with my K&N. After I removed the snorkel, I get a audible humming noise, that some people might find annoying. I put a K&N in my 99 Mazda Miata, and I didn't notice any performance increase, but I'll still keep it in there. Peaty, and others have recommended re-oiling there K&N yearly...I usually do mine every other year (about 16K miles). As far as more dirt getting into the engine...probably right. What does that mean in the long run? I'll only get 220K miles instead of 250K miles???? Take care...jim
 
In
y_p_w said:
I've used a K&N filter before. Their own literature claims that their oiled gauze filters are more effective at trapping dirt when dirt has already built up, which increases the surface area. Of course when the dirt builds up, there's going to be more restriction.

I was speaking to cone filters, not the oiled gauze panel filter.
 
Ned Pike said:
In

I was speaking to cone filters, not the oiled gauze panel filter.

What kind of cone filter? K&N makes all sorts of drop-in replacement filters in panel/cylindrical/etc shapes, as well as "universal" cone filters with special air boxes that replace the factory ones.

K&N certainly isn't the be-all or end-all of air filters. Using an oiled-gauze filter requires a compromise in engine longevity, low-end power/driveability, and noise levels.

I'm a bit wary about the mileage claims. Regardless of all the other stuff, I'd think that if they really did provide consistent 2-5% mileage increases, most manufacturers would use them to increase the CAFE ratings. I once bought one for $30, so I'd guess that a carmaker could likely get them in bulk for $15-20. Ford and Honda have been going to 5W-20 oil to try to raise their mileage by less than 1% compared to 5W-30 oil.
 
I'm a bit wary about the mileage claims. Regardless of all the other
stuff, I'd think that if they really did provide consistent 2-5% mileage increases, most manufacturers would use them to increase the CAFE ratings.

RXP gas kicker significantly decreases emissions so why doesnt exxon et al add it to fuel? Money. How much more do slightly better speakers cost in bulk? Automakers do all they can to pinch every penny from production costs.
K&N certainly isn't the be-all or end-all of air filters. Using an oiled-gauze filter requires a compromise in engine longevity, low-end power/driveability, and noise levels.

IMO it is, Improvements in all you mentioned
plus it lasts forever,
 
y_p_w said:
I'm a bit wary about the mileage claims. Regardless of all the other stuff, I'd think that if they really did provide consistent 2-5% mileage increases, most manufacturers would use them to increase the CAFE ratings.

Agreed. I think they invest a tremendous amount in meeting CAFE, and pulling in the opposite direction is the fact that americans want to buy bigger, faster cars and trucks. If it were an easy way at that price to help meet CAFE requirements, I think they'd be all over it.

OTOH, a filter that requires proper maintanence, and if improperly used (e.g., over-oiled) can damage the MAF sensor (do current Subes use MAF, or do they now use a MAP sensor?) is a liability.
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
16,881
Messages
84,098
Members
16,645
Latest member
msb

Latest Threads

Back
Top