Key stuck in 2016 Legacy with 22,000 miles

Joined
Sep 30, 2025
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
We just paid $997 to repair our 2016 Legacy regarding a stuck key. The only way we could remove the key was to disconnect the battery! I understand that this was due to a fault with Subaru. We contacted Subaru Advocates and they refused to take responsibility.
 
The key is the only thing on the key ring.
The only service performed for $997 was replacement of the key shifter guide plate.
 
Thank you for your reply, Jason. The reason I have the Subaru is because I thought they were reliable. I’m a little disappointed that we had to disconnect the battery every time we removed the key at all only 22k miles. Subaru acknowledged that this was a problem with their manufacturing.
They are probably legally protected by not absorbing this cost, but they have lost a customer’s good faith.
 
Check for a TSB on this. I had a similar issue and it was a design issue with the shifter lever that was repaired for free a couple of years ago. I have a 2017 Outback.
 
Check for a TSB on this. I had a similar issue and it was a design issue with the shifter lever that was repaired for free a couple of years ago. I have a 2017 Outback.
Thank you. There was a problem with the design and there have been multiple issues reported. It was not considered a safety issue so a recall wasn’t implemented. They did offer an extension on the warranty but that expired last year. To get it fixed today at an authorized Subaru dealership you’re looking at $1000.
I have been going back and forth with the Subaru advocate but they aren’t budging. They did offer a $200 voucher for future service which I declined because I don’t feel that is adequate to compensate anyone with a low mileage vehicle that has a design fault by the manufacturer.
 
Thank you. There was a problem with the design and there have been multiple issues reported. It was not considered a safety issue so a recall wasn’t implemented. They did offer an extension on the warranty but that expired last year. To get it fixed today at an authorized Subaru dealership you’re looking at $1000.
I have been going back and forth with the Subaru advocate but they aren’t budging. They did offer a $200 voucher for future service which I declined because I don’t feel that is adequate to compensate anyone with a low mileage vehicle that has a design fault by the manufacturer.
I was lucky and found a good, independent Subaru shop in the last few months by word of mouth recommendations. Do you know any other Subaru owners who might be able to recommend an independent shop so you can break up with the dealerships? Won't help with this issue but may save you money over time?
 
I encountered that same problem with my 2018 Subara Legacy. Yesterday I had the shifter plate replaced at my own expense--$618. I argued with Subaru as well to no avail. Yes, there was a TSB about this issue, but unfortunately, my car did not start to act up until it expired. In the meantime I was told it was not a safety issue and I could just shake the steering wheel or move the shifter back and forth until the key released. I am now looking to trade this car for a Hyundai. It only has $39,000 miles. Shame on Subaru for not contacting owners prior to this issue.
 
I encountered that same problem with my 2018 Subara Legacy. Yesterday I had the shifter plate replaced at my own expense--$618. I argued with Subaru as well to no avail. Yes, there was a TSB about this issue, but unfortunately, my car did not start to act up until it expired. In the meantime I was told it was not a safety issue and I could just shake the steering wheel or move the shifter back and forth until the key released. I am now looking to trade this car for a Hyundai. It only has $39,000 miles. Shame on Subaru for not contacting owners prior to this issue.
This is a seperate issue than op, but if you are looking for reliability/quality, I'd recommend not going to hyundai. In my personal experience, they are a few steps down from subaru.
 
I encountered that same problem with my 2018 Subara Legacy. Yesterday I had the shifter plate replaced at my own expense--$618. I argued with Subaru as well to no avail. Yes, there was a TSB about this issue, but unfortunately, my car did not start to act up until it expired. In the meantime I was told it was not a safety issue and I could just shake the steering wheel or move the shifter back and forth until the key released. I am now looking to trade this car for a Hyundai. It only has $39,000 miles. Shame on Subaru for not contacting owners prior to this issue.
Moving the shifter back and forth worked for a short time but eventually we had to disconnect the battery to get the key out. You were fortunate to only pay $618. When my wife brought the car home from Reedman Toll with a receipt for $997 with an additional $39 for using a charge card, I went through the roof! Talking with Subaru’s customer advocacy was a joke. I have a 2020 Hyundai Palisade and love it.
I did have an Outback and it was ok, but the Hyundai is so much better.
 
Keys these days suck
The tumblers break
Subaru does not have the market cornered on key and tumbler failure
Ford started it with the Focus back in 01
We used to have to re key the tumblers for them on their recall
Research "bump key" to get yourself out of a jam someday
See key trouble often these days, thanks China
 
Yes, I have had that trouble with other cars, but thankfully I have never had that problem with my Subie.
There is a solenoid interlock with the transmission. The key cannot be removed until the transmission is in Park.
If the solenoid wears out, it will not release the key, or not "sense" that it is in Park! This can be very annoying!
On one of my older cars, the interlock was an actual cable that had come loose. I was able to adjust the cable and then it worked well.
Yes, I found out about the "bump key" when my first Subaru, a 1995 Outback, was stolen! It was 10 days before Christmas! Thieves have no mercy, and no respect for private property.
The Police took my report and told me that the thieves had probably used a "bump" key and then they told me that older Subaru cars were high on the list of stolen cars. When I got it back, I foolishly paid the Impound lot Fee to get it back because supposedly it had no damage. The locks were ruined, the radio was gone, and the engine had a blown head gasket. I totally wish that I had just left it there at the lot!
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
16,888
Messages
84,122
Members
16,654
Latest member
jv9999

Latest Threads

Back
Top